Skip to main content

The Struggle over the 15th Amendment continues today

Professor Sonia Jarvis told me she saw parallels between the struggle for passage of the 15th amendment in 1870 and the struggle for the Democratic nomination today. So I examined the issue. Why did Susan B. Anthony form the National Woman Suffrage Association in 1869 and leave the abolutionist movement? Did it have anything to do with the passage of the 15th amendment giving black men the right to vote but ignoring the demands of white women who wanted the 15th amendment to include the word, “sex” and not only “race.” Of course it did. White women who were advocating for the vote were furious that Congress would allow black men to vote before white women. The woman’s suffrage movement split over the issue - Fraces W. Harper and Lucy Stone worked for passage of the 15th amendment while Elizabeth C. Stanton and Susan B. Anthony refused. Anthony “exclaimed disparingly that two million more men were now made tyrants over an equal number of women who had formerly been their equals” (Riegel 1962). After all white women were educated. How could they be denied the vote when black men, many of whom were not educated, did get the vote? It wasn’t until 50 years later that women in 1920 with the passage of the 19th amendment succeeded in getting the vote. What parallel exists today? In the race for the Democratic nomination for President, Hillary Clinton proclaimed that Barack Obama is not experienced enough for the Presidency. How much difference is there between Hillary Clinton today and Susan B. Anthony in the 19th century? Both had a goal and that goal was more important than anything, even the right for black men to vote. There is an another interesting historical fact - decades after the 15th amendment was passed, Susan B. Anthony and Frederick Douglass renewed their friendship. Years later Susan B. Anthony spoke glowingly of Douglas’ efforts for woman’s suffarge at Douglass’ funeral. 1)Riegel, Robert. 1962 December. The Split of the Feminist Movement in 1869.” The Mississippi Historical Review, 49/3:485-496.


Popular posts from this blog

Free Trade?

What is free trade? Free trade means that nations agree to trade goods and services without government interference – no tariffs, no underlying government regulation. The concept of free trade is supported by mainstream economics (neoclassical) which assumes that there is a level playing field worldwide; that free trade means governments do not help the private sector.

However, we know that is not the case. China’s government has put enormous investment in certain of its industries. One example is solar energy. China’s government has invested in this industry with the result that China now leads the world in the production of solar panels. There are dozens of examples of governments investing in private companies to help them in the tough worldwide competition that has developed.

America companies who put their manufacturing plants in China benefit enormous. It is called the “free rider.”  American companies with manufacturing plants keep reaping all the rewards of selling…

Mayor de Blasio admits homelessness cannot be eliminated immediately.

After three years of blaming his predecessor, Mayor Bloomberg, for moving so slowly on housing the homeless, Mayor de Blasio finally admitted that it will take years to house so many homeless people. Perhaps it isn't all Mayor Bloomberg's fault.
   To add a different perspective, let us take a look at New York State and its inability to commit resources to the city's problem. During the Bloomberg administration, the state cut funding to the homeless from $164 million in FY2002 to $110 million in FY2012, a 33 percent cut.  In addition, the state cut the funding to one of the few programs to permanently house the homeless, the Advantage Program. Not only did the state cut the program, but the state also passed legislation that the city could not use other state funds for the program.
   Then of course there is the federal government that has cut millions of dollars out of the public housing budget that houses so many of people in poverty. Thanks to the federal government, t…